Lady smiling wrapped in bubble wrap
3 September, 2025 //

Is your marketing too safe? Time for some agile experimentation.

#Advice
#Insights

Barry Fisher, Founder and CEO at Pivale Drupal agency - a man with dark hair, a neat beard, moustache and glasses.
Written by Barry Fisher Founder & CEO

Barry is our founder and CEO, responsible for delivering on our mission statement and ensuring successful digital transformation for our clients. Barry oversees the majority of our consulting and digital transformation projects.

As a marketing leader in the modern business landscape, you're likely hearing a lot about agility. But what does it mean to have an agile marketing mindset? In plain terms, it means fostering a culture where you and your team are not afraid to go off-piste with ideas, try new things in a methodical way, and learn quickly from real customer feedback. In an enterprise B2B setting, this mindset shift can be especially powerful. Instead of sticking to the old playbook and lengthy campaigns that feel "safe," agile marketing encourages small experiments, rapid learning, and continuous adaptation to better meet your audience's needs. This article explores how you can adopt an agile mindset in your marketing team - creating a safe space for innovation, validating ideas with data, and ultimately delivering more value to your customers.

 

What is an agile marketing mindset?

An agile marketing mindset takes inspiration from agile software development, but it's really about flexibility, iteration, and responsiveness in your marketing approach. Traditional marketing often relies on long campaigns planned months in advance, with large bets placed on ideas that may or may not land. By contrast, an agile approach involves breaking your marketing initiatives into smaller pieces that you can execute quickly, measure, and adjust. It's about viewing problems as opportunities and staying open to change. Rather than seeing a campaign that underperforms as a failure, an agile marketer sees it as a source of insight - a chance to learn what customers didn't respond to and improve next time. This growth-oriented outlook means visualising what's possible instead of fixating on obstacles. In short, an agile mindset is optimistic and curious: always asking "What can we try next?" and "What did we learn?".

Crucially, agility doesn't mean chaos or lack of strategy. It means planning in shorter cycles and adapting based on evidence. You might set a quarterly or monthly goal (for example, improving lead quality or increasing product adoption in a certain segment), but instead of executing one big campaign to achieve it, you run a series of mini-campaigns or tests. Each iteration gives you data on what works. This way, you can double down on the approaches that show promise and scrap the ones that don't - before you've blown the whole budget on a single unproven idea. The result is a marketing strategy that's continually refined by real-world feedback, much like agile teams in other disciplines refine their products through iterative development.

 

Creating a safe space for experimentation

To truly embrace agility, you need to nurture a safe space for experimentation within your team. This starts with culture. Your team members - from senior managers to junior execs - must feel confident that proposing a bold idea or running a small experiment won't lead to punishment if it fails. In fact, small failures are an inevitable and valuable part of the learning process. Encourage your team to take calculated risks by rewarding effort and learning, not just success. As one guide on agile mindsets notes, thriving teams recognise and reward both team and personal effort, learn from past challenges, and deliberately create a safe environment for trying new ideas and taking calculated risks. When people trust that they won't be reprimanded for an honest experiment that didn't pan out, they're far more likely to share creative ideas that could become your next big win.

Creating this kind of environment also means leading by example. As a marketing executive, show that you too are willing to experiment and admit when something doesn't work. Normalise open discussions about lessons learned from campaigns. For instance, if a particular webinar failed to attract attendees, discuss it without blame: Was the timing off? Was the topic misaligned with audience interests? Could the promotional strategy be different? By analysing these factors openly, you demonstrate that the goal is not to avoid failure at all costs (an impossible task in marketing), but to learn from each attempt. Over time, this approach builds a team culture where innovation flourishes and people aren't just doing what everyone else in the industry is doing - they're actively looking for new and better ways to connect with your audience.

Working with a technical partner like Pivale, which blends deep listening with agile delivery, can help make these experiments low-friction. Our team connects strategy and execution using flexible technology - Drupal, AI, analytics and campaign tools - so you can run tests quickly and safely, without being held back by slow build times or rigid development cycles. In short, Pivale helps you turn ideas into reality in days, not weeks.

 

Show, Don't Tell: Validate ideas with data

One practical tactic for introducing agile methods is the mantra "show, don't tell." Rather than seeking approval for every new idea through endless meetings and presentations, try proving the idea on a small scale first. If a junior marketing exec has a creative campaign idea that breaks from the norm, consider letting them run a tiny pilot program under the radar. The key is to design it as a low-risk experiment: perhaps a limited-region ad campaign, a one-off email test to a small subscriber segment, or a short social media experiment. Don't feel the need to announce every marketing experiment you're doing in advance - simply do it, and then bring the data to the discussion once you have results.

This works best when you have a technical ally. Pivale's agile approach and integrated toolset, built on open source flexibility, mean that mini-campaigns can be stood up quickly, measured, and iterated. You're not fighting technical barriers - you’re simply testing and learning, so when the data shows promise, you're ready to scale with confidence.

This approach can significantly improve the art of convincing stakeholders. People may be sceptical of an unorthodox idea when it's just a proposal on paper. But if you can come back and show, for example, that "In our trial run with 200 customers, this new approach increased click-through by 15%," you shift the conversation. Real user feedback and hard numbers are hard to argue with. Once you have validated your approach with a sample of your audience, it becomes much easier to make the case for scaling up. Essentially, you're letting the experiment speak for itself. It's a bit like scientists sharing a discovery - you're not asking people to take a leap of faith, you're showing evidence that the idea has merit.

By adopting a "show, don't tell" mindset, you also cut through internal bureaucracy. In many organisations, especially large enterprises, the default mode is to hold meetings, align every stakeholder, and get permissions before trying anything. Agile marketing flips this around: try something small first, then expand on it. Of course, use common sense and stay within ethical and brand guidelines, but realise that not every idea requires months of committee review. Often, a simple A/B test or a week-long trial can give you enough insight to justify (or abandon) a bigger investment. This way, you conserve resources and political capital for the ideas that do show promise.

 

Start small and learn fast

An agile marketing mindset thrives on the principle of "start small, learn fast." Instead of betting the farm on one big campaign, break your initiatives into smaller experiments. For example, if you believe a new feature or product angle will resonate with customers, create a small campaign around it and measure the response. This could mean launching a mini landing page, a limited ad set, or a short content piece to gauge interest. The beauty of small experiments is that they are quick to set up, quick to execute, and quick to shut down if they're not working.

Consider the example of Santander's marketing team when they decided to overhaul their traditional campaign approach. The bank found that long marketing cycles with lengthy approval processes were holding them back. In response, they shifted to running two-week "sprint" campaigns: small, low-risk marketing pushes that could be evaluated rapidly. The results were telling - campaigns that performed well got more budget and attention, while less successful experiments were simply stopped and left behind. This iterative approach paid off. Santander reported measurable improvements after embracing continual experiments, including a 12% rise in customer loyalty and the highest Net Promoter Score in 17 years. In other words, by learning fast which ideas worked for their audience, they achieved outcomes that far surpassed their old method of betting on a few large campaigns.

The lesson here is to treat each marketing effort as a hypothesis. You're essentially saying, "We believe this message or tactic will drive engagement because of X reason, so let's test it." If the results come back positive - fantastic, you've found something that works and can scale it up. If not, it's not a failure; it's valuable information. You've ruled out an approach and documented why it didn't land. Was it the content? The timing? The target audience? By carefully recording these factors, you build an internal knowledge base of what doesn't work and why. Sometimes a failed experiment can be tweaked and tried again (maybe the core idea is sound but the execution needs adjustment), or it can spark a new idea altogether. This practice of continuous optimisation is at the heart of agile marketing.

Don't forget the power of variants and A/B tests in your experimentation toolkit. If you have an idea you really believe in, try a couple of variations to hedge your bets. For instance, if you're unsure whether it's the headline or the image that will make a difference in an ad, test both versions simultaneously on small segments. You might find that one tweak causes a significant uplift in user engagement. Modern digital channels make it relatively easy to run these controlled tests, so take advantage of that to learn what truly resonates with your audience.

 

Empower your team to take initiative

One of the biggest hurdles to agile marketing in organisations is the mindset of asking for permission. Junior marketing executives, in particular, may feel they need sign-off for every idea, especially if company culture has traditionally been top-down. To cultivate agility, you should empower your team to take initiative within clearly defined guardrails. Make it known that everyone's ideas are welcome to be tested - not just those from the highest paid person in the room. When a team member comes to you with a creative concept, instead of reflexively asking them to write a long proposal or waiting for the next quarterly planning session, ask: "How can we test this on a small scale now?"

This empowerment does two things. First, it harnesses the diversity of your team's creativity. Great ideas can come from anywhere, and often the people closest to a particular channel or customer segment have insights that higher-ups might miss. Second, it creates a sense of ownership and accountability. If a junior exec is allowed to run with their idea, they'll be highly motivated to make it succeed and to learn from the results. Even if the experiment doesn't yield a win, the fact that they were entrusted to try will build their confidence and experience.

Another aspect of empowering initiative is challenging the "we tried that before" mentality. In marketing, you'll often hear seasoned colleagues dismiss a suggestion with, "Oh, we did that two years ago and it didn't work." It's important to push back on this fatalism. Just because something didn't work before doesn't mean it won't work now. Context in marketing is always changing - audience tastes evolve, market conditions shift, new technologies emerge, and your own brand positioning might be different than it was in the past. An idea that once fell flat might thrive under new circumstances. Perhaps the tone was wrong last time, but now you know how to pitch it better. Maybe the market wasn't ready then, but now the need is acute. Or it could be that running that idea as one isolated campaign was ineffective, but as part of a broader mix of touchpoints it could contribute to success. (There's a well-known concept that a customer might need to interact with your brand several times - sometimes cited as seven touchpoints - before taking action. Whether or not the number is set in stone, the principle is that a mix of campaigns can work together to make an impact.) The bottom line is: don't let old failures become permanent taboos. Use past campaigns as learning material, but stay open-minded and encourage your team to revisit and reinvent ideas that they genuinely believe in.

 

Marketing is a probabilistic game - so play it!

Unlike engineering, marketing isn't a deterministic science where the same input always yields the same output. It's more of a probabilistic game, meaning you're dealing with likelihoods and odds. You can't guarantee that any given campaign will succeed, but you can increase your probability of success by running more experiments and learning from each outcome. Think of each marketing idea as a small bet. An agile marketer places many smart, small bets, rather than a few all-or-nothing ones. Over time, those bets with good odds and solid data behind them will pay off and more than cover the cost of the ones that don't.

To make this concrete, consider the experience of a fast-growing software company's marketing team (like the team at SEMRush, a marketing tech firm). They embraced experimentation so fully that testing and iterating became part of their DNA - A/B tests were running constantly, and decisions were driven by live feedback from customers. The result? Their average revenue growth in new markets shot up by over 90%, and they managed to acquire 500,000 new users in just 8 months. Those numbers aren't magic; they're the outcome of treating marketing like a series of experiments and doubling down on what works. When you start thinking in terms of probabilities, you realise that the more intelligent trials you conduct, the luckier you tend to get. Each campaign is no longer a make-or-break event, but part of a larger evolutionary process for your marketing strategy.

Adopting this mindset also helps temper the fear of failure. If one experiment doesn't work out, it's not a disaster - it's expected that some won't. By measuring and understanding why, you've essentially bought a piece of insight for a small fee. Over time, you accumulate a rich understanding of your market. You'll spot patterns: certain messages always resonate with a particular audience, or certain channels consistently underperform for your product. With this knowledge, you can allocate resources more wisely. This is methodical experimentation at work: trial, measurement, learning, and iteration.

 

Keep it about the customer

Agile or not, marketing ultimately succeeds only if it connects with the real desires, needs, and pain points of your audience. An agile approach actually puts a spotlight on understanding the customer, because you'll be constantly seeking feedback and observing how people respond to your mini-campaigns. Use this to your advantage: make your experiments as much about listening as talking. In every iteration, ask what you're learning about your audience's preferences.

To ensure you're staying customer-centric, start by grounding your ideas in audience insights. Talk to your sales team about what prospects are asking for. Look at customer support queries or social media comments to see what your customers care about (or struggle with). This will spark experiment ideas that address real concerns. For example, if you notice potential buyers often hesitate because they "don't have time to implement" your solution, you might experiment with a time-saving messaging angle or a quick-start toolkit in your marketing. If that experiment boosts engagement, it validates that you identified a true customer pain point.

Also, remember that a healthy conversation with your market is less about you and more about them. This means your content and campaigns shouldn't just be broadcasts of product features; they should tap into topics and stories that interest the customer. Agile marketing lets you try out different topics or narratives in small doses to see what clicks. Perhaps your audience responds more to success stories of peers, or maybe they engage more with industry trend analysis than with technical specs. By iteratively testing content themes, you'll zero in on what your audience finds relevant and build a stronger relationship with them. As one marketing guide puts it, the key is knowing your customers well enough to identify which topics interest them, and then building your content around those interests. The product pitch can be subtly woven in, but the hook is something the customer truly cares about.

Finally, use agile techniques to literally listen to your audience. Incorporate quick feedback mechanisms in your campaigns: a one-question poll at the end of a webinar, a feedback form after a download, or even direct outreach to a handful of customers after they respond to an offer. When you treat each marketing touchpoint as a chance to learn about the customer, you inevitably become more attuned to delivering value to them. In turn, your marketing becomes more effective because it's built on real, up-to-date understanding rather than static personas or old research.

 

Dare to be different to capture attention

In a crowded market, sometimes you have to zig when everyone else zags. Part of going off-piste with idea generation is daring to be different in order to capture your audience's attention. Advertising agencies have understood this for decades: some of the most famous marketing campaigns succeeded because they broke the rules and did something unexpected. This could mean a creative format, a bold message, or an unconventional channel - anything that makes your audience do a double-take (in a good way).

For enterprise marketers, "daring to be different" might feel risky, but agile practices make it manageable. Why? Because you're not betting your whole brand on one crazy stunt - you're testing the bold idea on a small scale first. If it resonates, then you can roll it out bigger. If it doesn't, you've learned with minimal downside. For example, instead of sticking only to serious white papers and standard webinars like every other B2B firm, you might experiment with something more engaging or entertaining. One well-known B2B example was when Volvo Trucks released a whimsical yet jaw-dropping online video of an action movie star performing a split between two moving trucks. A stunt like that was unheard of in truck marketing - it was playful and a stark departure from dry spec sheets. That video went viral globally, generated massive buzz, and ultimately strengthened Volvo's brand in the eyes of customers. Now, a campaign of that scale isn't something you can test in a week, but the principle holds: the idea started with thinking outside the typical marketing box. Your version might be trying a witty animated video to explain a complex product, or incorporating a bit of humour into a normally stuffy subject, just to see how your audience reacts.

Even in experiments that are smaller, focus on what will truly surprise and delight your specific audience. In practice, being different for its own sake isn't the goal - being meaningful and memorable is. That often comes from creative insight into your audience. If all your competitors are using stock photos and generic messages, maybe your experiment is to use a more authentic, human tone with candid images. If other firms in your field avoid talking about a certain pain point openly, perhaps you address it head-on in a thought leadership piece. When you find that angle that makes your customers say "finally, someone gets it!" or "I didn't expect a company like this to do that," you'll know you've hit on something powerful.

The key takeaway is that agility in marketing gives you the freedom to try bold ideas without reckless gamble. You're not just being different for fun - you're being different in a disciplined way, always measuring the impact. And when the impact is strong, it justifies the bolder direction. In the end, what seems off-piste today can become your brand's signature approach tomorrow, setting you apart in the marketplace.

 

Conclusion: Take the leap and start experimenting

Adopting an agile marketing mindset is about breaking free from the fear of the unknown and replacing it with curiosity and confidence. By encouraging experimentation, fostering a culture that learns from failure, and keeping a relentless focus on your audience, you position your marketing team to do its most impactful work. This is a plain and friendly call to action: start small, but start now. Identify one idea that you believe could benefit your business - maybe something that's been on the back of your mind or a suggestion from a team member that got shelved - and find a way to test it in the next couple of weeks. Treat it as a learning opportunity regardless of outcome.

Remember, even the smallest experiment can spark a big change. Marketing isn't a precise equation; it's a dynamic interplay of creativity, data, and human behaviour. When you play it as a probabilistic game - placing thoughtful little bets, listening to feedback, and iterating - you create a momentum that outpaces more static, conventional strategies. Your team will become more engaged and proactive, your campaigns will become sharper and more resonant, and your business will see the difference in tangible results.

So go ahead: give your team permission to venture off the beaten path. Nurture those off-piste ideas and guide them with methodical testing. Celebrate the lessons learned, whether the experiment succeeds or "fails forward." By doing so, you'll cultivate not just better marketing outcomes, but a team that's resilient, creative, and genuinely agile in the face of whatever the market throws your way. And that is a competitive advantage no marketer should pass up. Embrace the agile mindset, and watch your marketing innovation, and your results , soar.

 

Ideas to spark your next agile marketing experiments

If you're wondering what kinds of experiments are worth trying, here are some creative directions to inspire you. They're not blueprints, but springboards for your imagination. The point is to stay small, fast, and curious.

You might test a playful variation of your usual tone of voice. If your brand has always sounded corporate and formal, try a piece of content written with warmth or humour. Sometimes even a subtle change in personality can shift how your audience engages.

You could explore timing. Send a campaign at an unexpected hour to see if your audience is more receptive when there's less noise in their inbox or feed. Marketers often assume standard schedules are best, but you may find new rhythms that work better for your market.

Experiment with format. If you usually write long-form thought leadership pieces, try distilling one idea into a short video, an interactive demo, or even a single striking graphic. The change in medium can reveal whether your message travels further when packaged differently.

Test transparency. Share a behind-the-scenes look at how your team works, or highlight the challenges you've faced alongside the successes. This kind of honesty often builds trust in unexpected ways.

You might also revisit old campaigns with a twist. Take an idea that didn't fly the first time and relaunch it with a fresh angle, sharper visuals, or a tie-in to a current trend. Context changes, and so do audience perceptions.

Finally, consider surprising your audience with generosity. Offer something useful with no strings attached - such as a free tool, template, or resource - and watch how it influences perception and long-term engagement.

The best experiments aren't always the most complex. They're the ones that teach you something new about your audience and spark your next creative leap.

 

Even bolder experiments to challenge "safe" marketing:

You could flip your messaging completely. If your campaigns are usually all about polished success stories, run a piece that highlights failures, lessons learned, and mistakes your customers should avoid. Honesty and vulnerability can stand out powerfully in markets where everyone claims perfection.

Try radically shortening your funnel. Instead of the usual gated whitepaper or form-heavy landing page, launch a campaign where you give away your best insights openly - no forms, no hoops. Then measure if this generosity builds more goodwill and brand visibility than your traditional lead-gen tactics. Just remember to prime your sales team to ask where they came from as you won't have you usual attribution/acquisition metrics. Don't be afraid of this!

Break the mould with tone and creativity. If your industry is known for dry, serious messaging, inject humour, satire, or storytelling. Imagine a B2B SaaS company making a mock "infomercial" for its product, or a legal firm running a tongue-in-cheek video series. The surprise factor alone could generate excellent engagement.

Play with audience targeting in unexpected places. Run a pilot ad campaign on a channel no one in your industry touches. For example, testing TikTok to reach decision makers who are also consumers, or Reddit to spark candid discussion. Even if it flops, the learning is valuable.

Experiment with scarcity and exclusivity. Instead of pushing everything to everyone, invite a small group of prospects into a private beta, a hidden microsite, or an invite-only webinar. See how exclusivity changes perception and interest.

Or go physical in a digital world. Send a handful of high-value prospects something tangible, playful, or provocative in the post and measure whether it cuts through better than another email nurture stream. We did this with our DayOne Digital offering: it plays on the time when you'd buy software in a physical box. A touch of nostalgia, if you will.

 

If you want more specific ideas for your next marketing experiments - do get in touch and we'll be happy to explore them with you. 

 

Partnering with a technical team like Pivale, which combines strategic clarity, agile delivery and a flexible Drupal-based platform, gives you the foundation to experiment confidently, adapt fast and make marketing innovation happen at speed.

Barry Fisher, Founder and CEO at Pivale Drupal agency - a man with dark hair, a neat beard, moustache and glasses.
Written by Barry Fisher Founder & CEO

Barry is our founder and CEO, responsible for delivering on our mission statement and ensuring successful digital transformation for our clients. Barry oversees the majority of our consulting and digital transformation projects.

Pri Scarabelli, Frontend Developer at Pivale digital transformation agency - a woman with dark hair, glasses, and a big smile

Contact us



Or send us a message...